Tabletop Nightmare: GM Spawns Impossible Boss, Encourages Teammate Betrayal, and Bans Player for Feedback

What was supposed to be a thrilling night of investigative horror quickly descended into an absolute exercise in frustration for one tabletop gamer after joining a new online group.

The player signed up for a single-session game using the Ordem Paranormal system, explicitely verifying with the Game Master beforehand that the scenario would focus on clues, deduction, and investigation. Relying on that commitment, they built a specialized investigator character designed to uncover occult secrets.

Read nextTwo-Year D&D Campaign Ends in Pure Chaos After Secret Traitor Wipes Out Friend Group!

However, upon entering the voice call, red flags appeared almost immediately. The table was divided between established friends—including the Discord server owner—and isolated newcomers. Once the session began, the GM frequently forgot the new players existed, while established players accused the newcomer of meta-gaming simply for offering basic in-character theories.

The situation escalated dramatically once the party entered the woods. Without calling for standard perception checks or honoring the player's specialized detection abilities, the GM dealt arbitrary, massive damage to the party out of nowhere. Moments later, the GM introduced a homebrew monster based on Slenderman with a threat rating mathematically impossible for the party's low-level rank.

As the group scrambled to escape the unwinnable encounter, player characters were picked off one by one. With only two survivors left, the server owner turned his weapon on his teammate, shooting them in the leg to guarantee his own escape. When the injured player asked to roll an evasion or reaction check, the GM outright denied the request, letting the monster execute the character while the server owner struck a deal with the dark entity.

When the session concluded, the GM asked the group for feedback. The player offered a polite critique, noting that they had hoped for more investigative elements rather than a lethal slasher scenario, while emphasizing it was just personal feedback for an otherwise potential-filled GM.

The response was immediate and hostile. The GM and server owner launched into verbal insults, claiming the player was bitter because their character wasn't the star of the show, before promptly banning them from the server entirely.

Commenters analyzing the collapse pointed out classic signs of tabletop favoritism. One person argued that if a GM treats guest players as disposable props for a server owner's scripted hero moment, they miss the fundamental point of collaborative storytelling. Another gamer noted that dropping an unwinnable boss while stripping away basic player defense rolls isn't horror—it's just a GM power trip.

On the podcast, our hosts tear into this tabletop disaster, debating where horror ambiance ends and bad game mastering begins.