He Hated 'The Hobbit' as a Preteen — Until He Read It to His Toddler and Realized He Was Completely Wrong

For nearly twenty years, one reader carried a deeply held grudge against J.R.R. Tolkien. Having fallen in love with the high-octane battles of Peter Jackson’s film adaptations as a twelve-year-old, picking up *The Hobbit* expecting non-stop adrenaline was a massive letdown. Discouraged by ten pages of dwarf feasting and barely a single page devoted to a troll fight, the book was abandoned, written off as slow, tedious, and boring.

Fast forward to parenthood. Facing the nightly bedtime ritual with a three-year-old daughter, a decision was made on a whim to pick up a copy of *The Hobbit* illustrated by Jemima Catlin. What followed was an unexpected eight-month literary journey that completely transformed one parent's view of classic fantasy.

Read nextThe 'Second Book Syndrome' Epidemic: Why Can't Fantasy Trilogies Stay Flawless?

Reading just a few pages each night, the bedtime routine became a magical experience. Scarier scenes were subtly edited on the fly, while dwarf songs were performed in low, booming voices. The three-year-old quickly became obsessed—fingers pretending to 'gobble up' the golden treasure on the full-page illustration of Smaug, and eventually naming her curly-haired, bare-footed younger brother 'Bilbo.' Finishing the 340-page epic felt like a monumental achievement, but it created an immediate dilemma: what could possibly follow it?

Attempts to transition into *The Tale of Despereaux*, *The Chronicles of Narnia*, and *Redwall* met brick walls. Either the prose felt too advanced or the initial hook failed to hold a toddler's fleeting attention span. The experience highlighted the unique brilliance of Tolkien’s original work—its self-contained episodic chapters, poetic rhythm, and warm oral storytelling tradition make it uniquely suited for bedtime read-alouds.

The discovery sparked a fiery conversation among literary enthusiasts about what books modern children are truly capable of enjoying. One commenter argued that parents routinely underestimate young listeners, advocating for subtle classics like *Winnie-the-Pooh* or *The Wind in the Willows*. Another suggested that the subtle wit and poetic cadence of AA Milne or Kenneth Grahame work wonders on young minds long before they fully grasp the plot.

Conversely, other readers urged caution, noting that *The Hobbit* might be a structural unicorn. Forcing dense, high-level prose like *Earthsea* or *The Chronicles of Prydain* on a four-year-old could easily backfire and extinguish a child's early enthusiasm for books. Recommendations ranged from age-appropriate serialized adventures like Patricia Wrede’s *Dealing with Dragons* to visual companion stories like Studio Ghibli's film version of *Howl's Moving Castle*.

The struggle to find the perfect literary fit isn't limited to children's books either. The search for compelling fiction spans all ages and genres—from parents seeking cozy fantasy for bedtimes to adult sci-fi fans hunting down underground fan translations of obscure cyberpunk novels like Roger Williams' *The Metamorphosis of Prime Intellect*.

Our podcast hosts take a closer look into this bedtime dilemma, debating whether classic fantasy belongs in the nursery or if modern parents are setting their expectations too high.